Memorandum of Understanding
The High Energy Astrophysics Science Archive Research Center
The National Space Science Data Center /
The World Data Center for Rockets and Satellites
Dated: April 18, 1997
Several NASA advisory boards have recommended that the most effective
method to manage a data archive, is to co-locate it with active scientists who
understand the contents and can provide expert advice and assistance. To this
end NASA has established several discipline specific nodes for archiving
astrophysics data, including in December 1990 the High Energy Astrophysics
Science Archive Research Center (HEASARC) for X-ray and Gamma-ray astronomy
data. This Memorandum of Understanding (MOU) redefines the roles of the
National Space Science Data Center (NSSDC), the World Data Center A for Rockets
and Satellites (WDCA R&S) and HEASARC in preserving and facilitating access
to data from X-ray and Gamma-ray astronomy missions. It updates and supersedes
a previous MOU concerning the NSSDC-HEASARC interaction made between the NSSDC
and the Office of Guest Investigator Programs (November 17, 1992).
This revised MOU takes into account the lessons learned and computer technology
advances over the past four years of HEASARC and NSSDC activities. The
emergence of the Space Science Data System is also consistent with this MOU.
It also uses as a guideline the report from the "Task Group on Science Data
Management" (the Linsky report) which was produced in October 1996. In the
original MOU the data management function (the physical archive) is the
responsibility of the NSSDC, and the archive interface' the responsibility of
the HEASARC. The dramatic reduction in the cost of mass storage, systems has
made it possible for the HEASARC to provide a dedicated archive to support its
users. This has enabled direct ftp access to the entire data holding, provided
greater speed for data access and more flexibility in maintaining the
archive. Simultaneously, the development of the world wide web has made it
possible to integrate the data and services from various disciplines and remote
data nodes in ways that were not anticipated when the HEASARC was created.
Over the past four years the HEASARC has effectively demonstrated that it can
provide a high energy astrophysics node that effectively fulfills all the NASA
requirements for archiving, maintaining and distributing data. This has led to
some duplication in effort between the data services provided by the NSSDC and
the HEASARC. This new MOU redefines the respective roles of the NSSDC and
HEASARC. It transfers to the HEASARC full responsibility for all of NASA's
high energy astrophysics archive and the community access to it. In this new
arrangement the NSSDC (or any future organization so designated by NASA HQ)
will hold a back-up copy of the HEASARC archive in a secure environment and
provide broad data standards to ensure the HEASARC archive conforms to minimum
NASA data standards.
The purpose of this document is to describe the roles of the NSSDC, the
WDCA R&S and the HEASARC in acquiring, archiving, and distributing high
energy astrophysics data (primarily consisting of X-ray and Gamma-ray astronomy
data). This document sets the general constraints on the interfaces between
the NSSDC, the WDCA R&S and the HEASARC. It supersedes a previous MOU
between the NSSDC and the Office of Guest Investigator Programs (November 17,
1992). Additional implementation details will be specified in future documents
which govern the details of the interface between NSSDC and the
The scope of this document covers areas of operation where there is
joint responsibility between the HEASARC, NSSDC and WDCA R&S, or where,
despite possibilities of ambiguity, there is sole responsibility of one or the
other. Other documents exist which describe the full range of operations of
The following groups are the intended audience for the document:
1. The staffs of the NSSDC, WDCA R&S, and HEASARC.
2. The HEASARC, NSSDC and other NASA advisory groups.
3. Those who are preparing or restoring high energy astrophysics data such as
Principal Investigators, and data restorers
4. Those who access high energy astrophysics data.
5. NASA Headquarters personnel who manage and provide the operating funds for
the NSSDC and HEASARC.
6. Managers of institutions participating in NSSDC and HEASARC activities.
7. Members of other data centers.
The following are the key components of this MOU
(a) The HEASARC will serve as the point of entry for all high energy
astrophysics (X-ray and Gamma-ray astronomy) data and software into the NASA
(b) The NSSDC shall maintain and coordinate broad standards for data
management and archiving which are appropriate to most or all disciplines and
recommend, maintain and monitor implementation of minimum NASA data
(c) The HEASARC shall be responsible for establishing and maintaining
standards for data structures, data formats and software which are appropriate
for use by the high energy astrophysics community and consistent with the broad
data standards defined by the NSSDC.
(d) The HEASARC serves as the primary interface with the high energy
astrophysics data producers, obtaining the data, analysis software, and
documentation. The HEASARC will validate the delivered items for format,
portability, completeness and content.
(e) The HEASARC will be the primary interface to the user community and will
provide for all electronic distribution of the archival high energy
astrophysics data sets, associated analysis software and documentation. The
HEASARC will also distribute to its user community data and software on media
such as CD ROM, DVD and-tape, where it is appropriate and cost effective to do
(f) The HEASARC will deliver at regular intervals a backup copy of the archive
along with the associated catalogs and documentation. The NSSDC will maintain
this backup copy as a "deep archive" to be used to restore the HEASARC primary
archive in the event of a catastrophic loss of the primary archive. The
back-up copy will be in a mutually agreed format, that will be primarily
designed to rapidly restore, in a cost effective manner the HEASARC archive.
(g) The NSSDC will be the primary interface for bulk distributions of entire
mission datasets and other large distributions. The NSSDC will provide
distributions from its pre-HEASARC data holdings, restoration of old data
tapes, and public/multidiscipline CD-ROM/DVD distribution.
(h) The NSSDC will maintain and operate the NASA master directory (which is to
be inclusive of all NASA space science data, regardless of the discipline node
where they reside). The HEASARC shall support the population of the master
directory. In addition the HEASARC will maintain a catalog of its data holding
and user interface to the online archive.
(i) The WDCA R&S will provide the auspices for international data requests
from the HEASARC data holding (as currently defined for the NSSDC).
F. MOU Review Procedures
This MOU will be annually reviewed by the NSSDC, the WDCA R&S, the
HEASARC and their advisory groups to determine each organization's compliance.
Any statements in the MOU that conflict with the current policy and procedures
will be identified. The reasons for these discrepancies will be reviewed and
either the MOU modified, or the operations policies revised to resolve the
Any conflicts or discrepancies related to the roles of the NSSDC, WDCA R&S
and HEASARC with respect to the MOU will be resolved by the directors of those
organizations. In the event that resolution is not possible at this level, the
matter will be elevated to NASA Headquarters, where the appropriate program
sponsors will help resolve the issue.
The HEASARC is the NASA discipline node that supports multi-mission
X-ray and Gamma-ray astronomy archival research. Following the recommendation
of several NASA advisory groups, the HEASARC was established in November 1990
in the Laboratory for High Energy Astrophysics at the GSFC with a charter to:
- maintain and disseminate data from previous and concurrent high energy
- provide software and data analysis support for these datasets;
- maintain and provide the necessary scientific and technical expertise for the
processing and interpretation of the data holding;
- develop and maintain multi-mission analysis and support tools;
- provide catalogs of observations and ancillary information for the data
- coordinate data, software and media standards with other astrophysics
Since 1965, the NSSDC has archived and disseminated data across the spectrum of
Space Science and Earth Science disciplines. The NSSDC provides access to a
wide variety of astrophysics, space physics, solar physics, lunar and planetary
data from NASA space flight missions, in addition to selected other data and
some models and software. NSSDC provides access to online information bases
about NASA and non-NASA data at the NSSDC and elsewhere as well as the
spacecraft and experiments that have or will provide public access data. NSSDC
also provides information and support relative to data management standards and
C. WDCA R&S
The World Data Center system is an international confederation of data
centers originally established in 1955 to support the exchange and archiving of
data generated by the 1957-8 International Geophysical Year. WDCA R&S is
hosted by NSSDC and has responsibilities for spacecraft launch and other
descriptive information capture and dissemination. WDCA R&S serves as a
conduit for requests from the international community for data from the NSSDC
IV. Project Interface
The HEASARC will serve as the point of entry for archival data from all
NASA-sponsored satellite based high energy astrophysics missions and
investigations (X-ray and Gamma-ray astronomy data). The HEASARC will maintain
a mission interface which is responsible for negotiating the individual Project
Data Management Plans (PDMPs) which satisfy the OSS Policy on Science Data
Management in anticipation of HQ/SR signature of the PDMP's. The data,
software and catalogs to be delivered will be specified in the prelaunch PDMPs
and may be augmented by agreement with HEASARC based on inflight experience.
These data products will include raw science data, ancillary data, higher
level data products, catalogs and relevant documentation. In all cases the
HEASARC will have signature authority over the PDMP. All active mission data
products that enter the NASA archive environment through the HEASARC mission
interface will be validated and archived. Back-up copies will be passed onto
NSSDC for safe keeping.
The HEASARC will be the archive entry point for all high energy astrophysics
data restored from past missions. The NSSDC will continue to hold and
distribute high energy astrophysics data from the pre-HEASARC era, until such
time as the HEASARC, its user group and NASA headquarters decide otherwise.
The HEASARC and NSSDC will agree on and document the terms covering the
transmission of archive products from HEASARC to NSSDC such as media type,
volume and frequency of delivery. The HEASARC and NSSDC will also agree on the
procedure for the restoration of the HEASARC archive in the event of a
The HEASARC will be responsible for the long term maintenance of the data
archive, and its migration to new media before it becomes obsolete or
The HEASARC will support international requests for high energy astrophysics
data in its holdings made to the WDCA (hosted by the NSSDC). Requests for data
may be made directly to the HEASARC. The HEASARC will make a best effort to
keep a record of all international data requests, and send a summary to the
WDCA director if requested.
The HEASARC will maintain a catalog of its data holding which allows users to
conveniently locate and retrieve data. This catalog will contain links to data
files in the physical archive
The NSSDC will maintain a multidisciplinary NASA master directory which will
contain high level information about the HEASARC data holdings Appropriate high
level information about the HEASARC data holdings will be sent to the NSSDC's
master directory via the Directory Interchange Format (DIF). NSSDC will
provide instructions to HEASARC in the appropriate use of the DIF format and
will review HEASARC entries in the master directory. NSSDC will also maintain
electronic links into the HEASARC catalogs from the master directory. HEASARC
will provide spacecraft and experiment level information to the NSSDC Master
Directory for new high energy astrophysics missions and experiments For each
new data set sent to the NSSDC, HEASARC will also send a completed data set
description template to be used by NSSDC in populating the NSSDC master catalog
at the data set level.
The NSSDC shall coordinate the Master Directory design and evolution to meet
mutual budget and system scope constraints. All changes made to the master
directory design that will require HEASARC to develop and/or modify their
operational system shall first be coordinated and agreed with HEASARC.
A. Data preparation
(i) Mission Data: As described in Section IV, all NASA high energy
astrophysics data will enter the NASA archive environment through the HEASARC.
The HEASARC will agree ahead of time with the relevant data provider on the
products to be delivered, and these will be summarized in a PDMP. Upon
delivery the HEASARC will verify the correct format, completeness, and
continuity of the data and will monitor the validity and content of the
incoming data. The HEASARC will also verify the completeness and contents of
the associated catalog data and documentation.
(ii) Restored Data: The restoration of old high energy astrophysics data will
be coordinated and overseen by the HEASARC. The priorities for data
restoration will be set by the HEASARC users group and via proposals to NASA.
As with mission data sets, the restored data sets will result in the update of
the HEASARC mission catalogs and the relevant Master Directory entries.
(iii) International Data: Data from foreign missions may also be ingested into
the HEASARC, as international agreements allow. The HEASARC will coordinate
and cooperate with international agencies to ensure the data from foreign
missions follow HEASARC standards and will seek to maximize the access to the
complete world-wide high energy astrophysics dataset..
B. Data Storage
The final archive site for data from NASA sponsored high energy
astrophysics missions will be at the HEASARC. In those cases where the mission
is still actively modifying its data the physical archive may be remotely
located at another site. In these cases the HEASARC catalog will contain
entries and pointers to these data at the remote site. Every effort will be
made to obtain a copy of the archive at the HEASARC as soon as is practical and
The HEASARC will provide to the NSSDC a backup copy of the entire locally
stored HEASARC data holding, software and associated catalogs. The NSSDC will
hold this copy of the archive in a secure off-line environment, which will not
be directly accessible by the outside community. The HEASARC will only send to
the NSSDC back-up copies on a mission by mission basis of those data sets
directly under its control. This backup copy will be optimized to be in a form
that the HEASARC can use to quickly restore the primary archive in the event of
a data loss. It will be the responsibility of the HEASARC to validate the
correctness of these backup tapes before they are delivered to the NSSDC..
C. Data Distribution
The HEASARC will as resources and technology allows maintain its entire
data holding online for immediate network access. Network distribution of the
data will be the prime method of data dissemination from the HEASARC. Requests
for moderate volumes of data on a distribution medium (tape, CD ROM, DVD) will
be supported by the HEASARC on a case by case basis. Those cases where large
volumes of data are requested, in particular an entire mission data set, the
HEASARC may request the NSSDC to make a bulk copy from the backup tapes and
send the copies to the requester. In these cases the NSSDC will apply its
normal charging policy for each copy.
HEASARC will put the most popular datasets of a manageable size onto CD ROM, or
DVD. When the initial procurement is made, the NSSDC will simultaneously
procure a set of CDs. Both the NSSDC and HEASARC will fulfill requests for CD
ROM or DVD media. The HEASARC will concentrate on distribution to its user
community, the NSSDC requests from the general public, again following its
normal charging policy.
VII. User support
The HEASARC has prime responsibility to support users of the high energy
astrophysics archives. This will include providing expert advice on the
contents and use of the data holding. The current NSSDC documentation
(including web pages) that refer to high energy astrophysics data holdings will
be modified to redirect users to the HEASARC services.