XMM-Newton Users Handbook


next up previous contents
Next: 3.7.1 A comparison of XMM-Newton vs. Chandra Up: 3 XMM-Newton - a concise overview Previous: 3.6.2 Attitude & Orbit Control Subsystem (AOCS)


3.7 Comparison with other X-ray satellites

A basic comparison of XMM-Newton's properties with those of Chandra, ROSAT, ASCA, RXTE, Swift, Suzaku and NuSTAR is given in Table 27. It is immediately clear that Chandra and XMM-Newton have complementary characteristics and that both constitute a new generation of X-ray missions, with enormously improved capabilities compared to their predecessors ASCA, ROSAT and RXTE.


Table 27: Comparison of XMM-Newton with other X-ray satellites
Satellite Mirror PSF Mirror PSF E range A$_{\bf e}$ at 1 keV Orbital target Energy resolution
  FWHM [$~{\bf ''}$] HEW [$~{\bf ''}$] [keV] [cm$^{\bf 2}$]$^a$ visibility [hr] at 1 keV [eV]
XMM-Newton 6 15 0.15 - 12 4650$^b$ 36.7$^c$ 4 (RGS)
Chandra 0.2$^d$ 0.5$^d$ 0.1 - 10 555 (ACIS-S) 44.4$^c$ 1 (HETG)
ROSAT 3.5 7 0.1 - 2.4 400 1.3$^e$ 500
ASCA 73 174 0.5 - 10 350 0.9$^e$ 100
Suzaku n.av.$^g$ 120 0.2 - 600 1760 (XIS) 0.72$^e$ 50
RXTE n.a.$^g$ n.a.$^g$ 2-250 n.a.$^g$ 1$^e$ n.a.$^g$
Swift 8.8 18$^f$ 0.2-10 (XRT) 133.5 $\sim $0.8$^e$ 70
NuSTAR 18 n.av.$^g$ 3-79 n.a.$^g$ $\sim $0.8$^e$ n.a.$^g$
Notes to Table 27:
a) Mirror effective area.
b) Note that Figs. 11 and 12 do not just show the mirror effective areas but have the EPIC detector responses included as well.
c) Orbital visibility outside the particle-radiation dominated zone.
d) The Chandra High Resolution Camera (HRC) spatial response is well matched to the mirror resolution and the intrinsic on-axis PSF of the HRC is well modelled by a Gaussian with a FWHM of 0.4 arcsec. The spatial resolution for on-axis imaging with the ACIS instrument is limited by the physical size of the CCD pixels (0.492 arcsec) and not the mirrors.
e) Low orbit with Earth occultation.
f) At 1.5 keV.
g) n.av.: not available, n.a.: not applicable.


Some special strengths of XMM-Newton are e.g.:



Subsections
next up previous contents
Next: 3.7.1 A comparison of XMM-Newton vs. Chandra Up: 3 XMM-Newton - a concise overview Previous: 3.6.2 Attitude & Orbit Control Subsystem (AOCS)
European Space Agency - XMM-Newton Science Operations Centre